English Chapter 3: Reading Skills
Relative Clauses
3.14 Relative Clauses
ENGLISH • Form 4 • Grammar

Relative Clauses

Relative clauses add information about a noun. Learn which word to use, when you can leave it out and when you need commas.

Learning Objectives

  • Explain what a relative clause does in a sentence.
  • Choose who, whom, which, that or whose correctly.
  • Use where, when and why to start a relative clause.
  • Decide when a relative pronoun can be left out.
  • Tell defining from non-defining clauses and use commas correctly.

Commas Change the Meaning

The same words change meaning when commas go around them.

TELLS US WHICH ONES

Defining clause

The students who finished early went out to play.

Only some students finished early.

No commas.
ADDS EXTRA INFORMATION

Non-defining clause

The students, who finished early, went out to play.

All the students finished early.

Commas go around the clause.

Short Explanation

What relative clauses do and how to use them.

What a relative clause does

A relative clause adds information about a noun. It is a subordinate clause, so it cannot stand alone.

The teacher who runs the Science Club comes from Penang. The clause who runs the Science Club tells us more about the noun teacher.

Some relative clauses tell us exactly who or what we mean. Others only add extra information.

TypeExample
A defining clause tells us which person or thing we mean. We need it. The team that wins today will play in Kuching.
A non-defining clause adds extra information. We already know who or what we mean, so the sentence still works without it. Puan Salmah, who teaches us History, runs the school choir.

Three things can start a relative clause.

What starts itExample
A relative pronoun: who, which, that, whom, whose The teacher who runs the Science Club comes from Penang.
A relative adverb: where, when, why We buy kuih from the stall where Mak Cik Ani works.
No word at all, if the pronoun is an object in a defining clause The bag Mei Ling found belongs to the new teacher.

1. Relative pronouns

Pronoun and useExample
who: for people. It can be subject or object in the clause. The prefects thanked the cleaner who found the lost keys.
which: for animals and things. It can be subject or object in the clause.

The fan which cools our classroom makes a lot of noise.

The snack which my aunt makes sells out quickly.

which: can also refer to a whole sentence, not one noun. Put a comma before it. The rain stopped early, which made everyone happy.
whom: the object form of who. It is formal and more common in writing. In everyday English, who is more usual. It works in both defining and non-defining clauses.

The prefect whom we elected speaks at every assembly.

Our coach, whom the whole team respects, trains us on Fridays.

that: for people, animals and things. It can be subject or object. Use it in defining clauses only. Who or which can often replace it. The mural that covers the canteen wall took a month to paint.
whose: shows possession. It goes before a noun. The student whose poster won the contest is in my class.

2. Relative adverbs

Adverb and useExample
where: refers to a place This is the corner where the art club meets.
when: refers to a time The library closes early on days when there is a staff meeting.
why: refers to a reason The heat is the reason why the assembly was short.

3. Subject or object?

Look at what comes straight after who, which or that.

RuleExamples
Subject pronoun: a verb usually comes next. Do not leave the pronoun out.

The clock which hangs in the hall runs five minutes slow.

The librarian who helps us every week has retired.

Object pronoun: a noun or pronoun usually comes next. You can leave the pronoun out of a defining clause.

Mr Tan marked the essay (which/that) Hana wrote.

Everyone admires the coach (who/whom/that) Puan Salmah invited.

Whose works differently: it goes before a noun.

4. Defining clauses

A defining clause, also called a restrictive clause, tells us which person or thing we mean. Do not put commas around it.

  • The bus that stops outside our school is always full.
  • These clauses are useful for writing definitions. A goalkeeper is a player who guards the net.
  • An object pronoun in a defining clause can be left out. The speaker (who/whom/that) the prefects chose gave a short talk.

5. Non-defining clauses

A non-defining clause, also called a non-restrictive clause, adds extra information. We do not need it to know who or what we mean. Put commas around it. If it ends the sentence, one comma before it is enough.

  • Our school hall, which opened last year, has a new stage.
  • That cannot start a non-defining clause. Use who, whom, which or whose instead.
  • Do not leave the pronoun out of a non-defining clause, even when it is the object.
CorrectNot correct
Encik Rahman, who Aina interviewed for the school magazine, drives the school van. Encik Rahman, that Aina interviewed for the school magazine, drives the school van.
Encik Rahman, who Aina interviewed for the school magazine, drives the school van. Encik Rahman, Aina interviewed for the school magazine, drives the school van.

Try to Answer First

Try each one, then check your answer.

1

Add commas if they are needed: “Our principal who loves gardening planted these trees.”

2

Can you leave out the relative pronoun? (a) The essay that I wrote won a prize. (b) The girl that sits beside me is quiet.

3

Join the sentences with whose: “I know a girl. Her cat sleeps in the school library.”

Common Mistakes

Five mistakes to avoid.

1. Leaving out a subject pronoun

INCORRECT

The teacher runs the Science Club comes from Penang.

CORRECT

The teacher who runs the Science Club comes from Penang.

Who is the subject of runs, so it must stay.

2. Adding a second subject

INCORRECT

The girl who she won the quiz joined our school last month.

CORRECT

The girl who won the quiz joined our school last month.

Who is already the subject, so she is not needed.

3. Using that in a non-defining clause

INCORRECT

Puan Salmah, that teaches us History, runs the school choir.

CORRECT

Puan Salmah, who teaches us History, runs the school choir.

That cannot start a non-defining clause.

4. Using who for a thing

INCORRECT

The ruler who broke yesterday belonged to Hana.

CORRECT

The ruler which broke yesterday belonged to Hana.

Who is for people.

5. Putting a comma before a defining clause

INCORRECT

A goalkeeper is a player, who guards the net.

CORRECT

A goalkeeper is a player who guards the net.

The clause is needed, so no comma goes before it.

Concept Misunderstandings

Three ideas students often get wrong.

MISUNDERSTANDING

Every relative clause gives essential information.

FACT

Only a defining clause does. A non-defining clause adds extra information.

MISUNDERSTANDING

Whom is wrong in a defining clause.

FACT

Whom is correct in both types when it is the object. It is formal, so who is more usual in everyday English.

MISUNDERSTANDING

You can always leave out the relative pronoun.

FACT

You can leave it out only if it is an object in a defining clause.

Summary

The key points to remember.

  • A relative clause adds information about a noun.
  • A defining clause tells us which person or thing we mean and has no commas. A non-defining clause adds extra information and has commas.
  • Who is for people and which is for animals and things. That is for all three, in defining clauses only. Whose shows possession and whom is the formal object form.
  • Where, when and why refer to a place, a time and a reason.
  • Object pronouns can be left out of defining clauses. Subject pronouns stay.

Short Activity

Complete all three parts, then press Check Answer. Full marks: 8.

A. Objective Quiz: Relative Clauses

1 Which sentence is correct?

2 In which sentence can the relative pronoun be left out?

B. Fill in the Blanks: Relative Pronouns

3 Aina, (blank) sits beside me, won the quiz.

4 I spoke to the girl (blank) brother coaches our team.

C. Matching: Relative Words

Drag each sentence to the job of its bold word. On a phone or keyboard, select a sentence first, then select a box. To return a selection, select the item and press the Sentences area.

Sentences
The field where the cadets train is behind the hall.
We met a farmer whose goats won a prize.
I remember the morning when our class won the cup.
Nobody told us the reason why the bell rang early.
Jobs
1Points to a time 
2Explains the cause 
3Points to a location 
4Shows possession 

Keywords

Important terms in this topic.

relative clause defining clause non-defining clause restrictive clause non-restrictive clause relative pronoun relative adverb subject pronoun object pronoun